Welcome to
Treasure Island
Local Guide
Talk with Dillon Cook
Use this guide to get oriented, then get the street-level context before you buy or sell in Treasure Island.
Considering Treasure Island?
Tell me where you’re looking and what matters to you. I can help compare the neighborhoods, fees, and commute before you narrow the search.
Ask about this area
Send me a note
Prefer a call? Choose a time with Dillon.
Buyer / Seller Gauge
Months of supply points to buyer-favored conditions in Treasure Island.
Above 6 months of supply gives buyers more room to compare options, negotiate, and wait on listings that miss the mark.
City-level Redfin rows use rolling three-month windows; months of supply uses Redfin's published value when available and otherwise divides available supply by the monthly sales pace for the rolling window. When Redfin does not publish inventory for an area row, active listings are used as the supply proxy.
Source geography: City Treasure Island, FL. Source period: 2026-06-01 to 2026-08-31. Inventory: 185. Active listings counts properties listed during the source window; inventory is a separate supply measure.
Market dataset refreshed (UTC): Sep 12, 2026 14:57
Redfin Data Center Source period ending Aug 2026
About Treasure Island
About Treasure Island, Florida
Treasure Island is a Gulf-front beach city where tourism, boating, waterfront homes, condos, rental rules, flood risk, and insurance shape the housing decision. The current Redfin-backed snapshot shows a median sale price near $619,590 with 272 active listings, so pricing needs to be compared against real supply rather than broad county averages.
Demand is lifestyle and use-case driven; buyers compare beach access, boating utility, rental potential, ownership cost, and building health.
The current Treasure Island snapshot shows 272 active listings, 71 sales in the rolling three-month window, 8.0 mo of supply, a median sale price near $619,590, and about 134 days on market. Use that as a directional read, then compare the exact pocket and price band before making a decision.
Local Economy
What drives daily life and demand around Treasure Island?
Daily life is shaped by Gulf Boulevard, the beach, Blind Pass, Isle of Capri, Johns Pass proximity, local restaurants, and St. Petersburg bridges.
Commute and corridor access
Treasure Island is best for beach-centered or flexible routines; mainland, downtown St. Petersburg, and Tampa trips need seasonal traffic review.
Schools and address-level fit
Schools are usually secondary to lifestyle and investment use, but full-time buyers should verify assignment and mainland transportation.
Neighborhood structure and fees
Association rules, rental limits, reserves, assessments, parking, pets, insurance responsibilities, and waterfront maintenance can change economics quickly.
Insurance and property screening
Flood, elevation, wind insurance, roof age, seawall or dock condition, condo reserves, building condition, and storm exposure are central.
Common Questions
Is Treasure Island a good place to live?
Treasure Island is a Gulf-front beach city where tourism, boating, waterfront homes, condos, rental rules, flood risk, and insurance shape the housing decision. The current Redfin-backed snapshot shows a median sale price near $619,590 with 272 active listings, so pricing needs to be compared against real supply rather than broad county averages.
What matters when selling in Treasure Island?
Seller strategy in Treasure Island works best when the listing gives buyers a clear reason to choose the property: condition, location, updates, lower friction, or a better all-in payment than nearby alternatives.
What should buyers compare first in Treasure Island?
Regular buyers should compare use case, flood and insurance exposure, rental rules, association health, parking, bridge route, and nearby beach alternatives.
County Toolbelt
Pinellas County Toolbelt for Treasure Island
County-level links for taxes, zoning, code, safety, housing resources, research, and calculators.
Taxes and property
Zoning and codes
Safety and housing
Research and calculators
Census Snapshot
Treasure Island market snapshot
Use this as the numeric baseline. It is Census-backed context for how the area looks on paper before you get into property-level screening.
Market Read
How the numbers tend to translate on the ground
Demand is lifestyle and use-case driven; buyers compare beach access, boating utility, rental potential, ownership cost, and building health.
Regular buyers should compare use case, flood and insurance exposure, rental rules, association health, parking, bridge route, and nearby beach alternatives.
Seller strategy in Treasure Island works best when the listing gives buyers a clear reason to choose the property: condition, location, updates, lower friction, or a better all-in payment than nearby alternatives.
Investors in Treasure Island need to underwrite insurance, association rules, reserves, assessments, rental limits, seasonality, and realistic net income before assuming the lifestyle premium creates a deal.
See the complete Census tables 4 detailed groups
Census Data
People and households
- Households 3,853
- Housing units 6,192
- Under 18 3.5%
- Age 65+ 43.4%
- Average household size 1.7
Census Data
Economy and mobility
- Per capita income $82,911
- Bachelor degree or higher 50%
- Labor force participation 49.7%
- Unemployment 4.3%
- Poverty rate 6.7%
- Mean commute 32 min
- Public transportation 0.0%
- Work from home 36.1%
Census Data
Housing profile
- Detached single-family 35.7%
- Homeowner vacancy 0.0%
- Rental vacancy 23.8%
- Median gross rent $1,631
- Built 2000 or later 6.4%
Census Data
Housing costs
- Owner costs with mortgage $2,837
- Owner costs without mortgage $1,317
- Owner cost burden 35%+ 34.5%
- Rent burden 35%+ 37.1%
Schools
Treasure Island schools
Campus location does not establish enrollment eligibility. Verify your exact address, grade level, school year, and any choice or magnet application with the district.
Census place boundary: Treasure Island city. This list includes regular, nonvirtual public-school campuses in the 2024-25 NCES records. Check later openings and closures with the district.
District Snapshot
What to verify first
Treasure Island generally points to Pinellas County Schools, but exact address decides assignment and program eligibility.
- District Pinellas County Schools
- District grade 2026 A
- District grade 2025 A
- Matched public-school campuses 0
Schools are usually secondary to lifestyle and investment use, but full-time buyers should verify assignment and mainland transportation.
School Highlights
School locations and grades
This source did not match an open, regular public-school campus within the area shown. That does not mean residents have no school options; assigned schools may be outside this boundary.
The district can confirm which schools serve your address, including schools outside this community.
Living Here
Living in Treasure Island
This is the everyday layer: what people actually use, how the area moves, and which practical constraints start to matter once the headline city label is out of the way.
Daily Life
What residents actually use
Daily life is shaped by Gulf Boulevard, the beach, Blind Pass, Isle of Capri, Johns Pass proximity, local restaurants, and St. Petersburg bridges.
Movement
How routines connect to the rest of the county
Treasure Island is best for beach-centered or flexible routines; mainland, downtown St. Petersburg, and Tampa trips need seasonal traffic review.
Costs and constraints
What to screen early
Flood, elevation, wind insurance, roof age, seawall or dock condition, condo reserves, building condition, and storm exposure are central. Association rules, rental limits, reserves, assessments, parking, pets, insurance responsibilities, and waterfront maintenance can change economics quickly.
Explore Next
Compare nearby options and related context
Move from the local overview into nearby alternatives, deeper reads, videos, and common questions without losing the context you started with.
Nearby Alternatives
If Treasure Island is close but not quite right
- Madeira Beach Use this Pinellas County guide to orient around Madeira Beach, compare commute patterns, insurance or flood exposure, fees, housing fit, and nearby Tampa Bay alternatives.
- St. Pete Beach Use this Pinellas County guide to orient around St. Pete Beach, compare commute patterns, insurance or flood exposure, fees, housing fit, and nearby Tampa Bay alternatives.
- Redington Beach Use this Pinellas County guide to orient around Redington Beach, compare commute patterns, insurance or flood exposure, fees, housing fit, and nearby Tampa Bay alternatives.
Related Content
Deeper reads, videos, and questions
How do I buy and sell at the same time?
It is a juggling act, but it is doable with the right plan. The key is timing your sale and purchase so you are not stuck paying two mortgages or left without a place to live.
Sometimes that means listing your current home first with a flexible closing date. Other times it means making the purchase contingent on selling your current home. There are also options like rent-backs, short-term rentals, or using equity to bridge the gap. I walk clients through each scenario and the numbers behind it.
How far in advance should I plan if I am relocating to Tampa Bay?
Ideally, start planning three to six months in advance. That gives you time to research neighborhoods, get pre-approved for financing, schedule home tours, and arrange moving logistics.
If you are selling a home in another state, I can coordinate with your local agent so the timing is more controlled and you are not stuck in limbo between closings.
How long does it usually take to close in Tampa Bay?
Most closings in the Tampa Bay area take 30 to 45 days from contract to keys in hand. Cash deals can close in under two weeks, while VA, FHA, and conventional loans often take closer to 45 days.
The biggest factors affecting the timeline are financing, inspections, repairs when necessary, and appraisal. I help keep the process moving by coordinating directly with lenders, inspectors, and title companies.
Next Step
Talk through Treasure Island with a local plan
Bring the exact pocket, price band, sale plan, or investment angle into the conversation so the next move is based on the details that matter.